Current:Home > FinanceIllinois Supreme Court upholds state’s ban on semiautomatic weapons -MarketStream
Illinois Supreme Court upholds state’s ban on semiautomatic weapons
View
Date:2025-04-15 04:29:50
SPRINGFIELD, Ill. — The Illinois Supreme Court has upheld the state’s ban on the sale or possession of the type of semiautomatic weapons used in hundreds of mass killings nationally.
In a 4-3 decision Friday, the high court found that the Protect Our Communities Act does not violate the federal Constitution’s guarantee of equal protection of the law nor the state constitution’s bar on special legislation.
The court also decreed that state Rep. Dan Caulkins, a Decatur Republican, a Decatur pawn broker and like-minded Macon County gun-owners who brought the lawsuit had earlier waived their claims that the law infringes on the Second Amendment to own firearms and could not raise it before the Supreme Court. It’s a claim Caulkins’ attorney vehemently denies.
The Second Amendment claim is alive, however, in several federal lawsuits filed in southern Illinois, later consolidated and awaiting appeals court action.
The law bans dozens of specific brands or types of rifles and handguns, .50-caliber guns, attachments and rapid-firing devices. No rifle is allowed to accommodate more than 10 rounds, with a 15-round limit for handguns. The most popular gun targeted is the AR-15 rifle, which can be found in at least 25 million American households, according to 2021 research by Georgetown University.
But it carves out exceptions. Those who possessed semiautomatic guns before it became effective on Jan. 10 are allowed to keep them but must register them with the state police by Jan. 1, 2024. And seven categories of “trained professionals,” such as police officers, active-duty military, corrections officials and qualified security guards, may carry them.
Bolstered by the 2022 U.S. Supreme Court case that determined Americans have a right to carry weapons in public for self-defense, Caulkins argued that the plaintiffs and those granted exemptions to the ban are “similarly situated” in that they all hold required Firearm Owners Identification Cards and are protected by the Second Amendment, but were not given equal protection of the laws when the ban was applied to them.
Justice Elizabeth Rochford, writing for the majority, countered that in the case of grandfathered gun owners, there’s no dissimilar treatment. And just having a FOID card doesn’t mean a gun owner has arrest powers or other duties assigned to the trained professionals, nor the training and experience with the firearms they carry.
“The equal protection clause guarantees that similarly situated individuals will be treated in a similar manner, unless the government can demonstrate an appropriate reason to treat those individuals differently,” Rochford wrote. “The equal protection clause does not forbid the Legislature from drawing distinctions in legislation among different categories of people as long as the Legislature does not draw those distinctions based on criteria wholly unrelated to the legislation’s purpose.”
Caulkins’ attorney, Jerrold Stocks, said additional legal action was likely, including a potential appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court.
Democratic Gov. J.B. Pritzker signed the Protect Our Communities Act hours after lawmakers sent it to him in a lame-duck session in January, months after a shooter using a high-powered rifle killed seven and injured dozens on Independence Day 2022 in the Chicago suburb of Highland Park. The new law set off a firestorm of criticism from gun-rights advocates, including county sheriffs who were nearly unanimous in signing a statement that they would not zealously enforce the law.
“This is a commonsense gun reform law to keep mass-killing machines off of our streets and out of our schools, malls, parks, and places of worship,” Pritzker said in a statement. “Illinoisans deserve to feel safe in every corner of our state — whether they are attending a Fourth of July Parade or heading to work — and that’s precisely what the Protect Illinois Communities Act accomplishes.”
The court’s fifth Democrat, Justice Mary K. O’Brien, dissented, deciding the law is illegal special legislation that gives some of the excepted classes — retired police officers, for example — rights to the weapons, without rationale, that the plaintiffs don’t have.
The court’s two Republicans, Justices Lisa Holder White and David Overstreet, filed a separate dissent. They found that lawmakers so blatantly violated the constitutional procedures for approving legislation as to make the law unconstitutional, “thereby obviating the need to address the firearm restrictions at issue in this appeal.”
“Important as this case is, constitutionally embedded process matters,” Holder White wrote. “Where the Legislature fails to honor our constitutionally mandated process, this court is duty bound to adhere to our constitution and require the Legislature to do the same.”
veryGood! (1132)
Related
- Man charged with murder in death of beloved Detroit-area neurosurgeon
- Outer Banks Ending After Season 5
- Georgia man arrested in Albany State University shooting that killed 1 and injured 4
- How to Build Your H&M Fall Capsule Wardrobe: Affordable Essentials to Upgrade Your Style
- $73.5M beach replenishment project starts in January at Jersey Shore
- California sues LA suburb for temporary ban of homeless shelters
- Rudy Giuliani cleared out his apartment weeks before court deadline to turn over assets, lawyers say
- Psychotropic Medications and High Heat Don’t Mix
- US appeals court rejects Nasdaq’s diversity rules for company boards
- NFL Week 9 winners, losers: Joe Flacco shows Colts botched QB call
Ranking
- Sonya Massey's family keeps eyes on 'full justice' one month after shooting
- From UConn three-peat to Duke star Cooper Flagg, the top men's basketball storylines to watch
- RHOBH's Teddi Mellencamp & Edwin Arroyave's Date of Separation Revealed in Divorce Filing
- Saquon Barkley reverse hurdle: Eagles' RB wows coach, fans with highlight reel play
- Messi injury update: Ankle 'better every day' but Inter Miami star yet to play Leagues Cup
- Jennifer Lopez's Sister Reunites With Ben Affleck's Daughter Violet at Yale Amid Divorce
- Control of Congress may come down to a handful of House races in New York
- Appeals court says Arizona should release list of voters with unverified citizenship
Recommendation
What polling shows about Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz, Harris’ new running mate
James Van Der Beek's Wife Kimberly Speaks Out After He Shares Cancer Diagnosis
2 Ohio officers charged with reckless homicide in April death of Frank Tyson
Olivia Rodrigo Reveals Her Biggest Dating Red Flag
Kansas City Chiefs CEO's Daughter Ava Hunt Hospitalized After Falling Down a Mountain
Ben Affleck Shares Surprising Compliment About Ex Jennifer Lopez Amid Divorce
Opinion: Women's sports are on the ballot in this election, too
Volvo, Ram, Ford among 252,000 vehicles recalled: Check recent car recalls here